Mary Peltola’s campaign took a hit in court just as Alaska’s razor-thin Senate race kept grinding forward, with election workers still sorting ballots and the margin tightening in the latest count. A judge rejected the campaign’s push for records tied to rejected absentee ballots, calling the request out of step with the moment and saying the election office was already slammed with counting duties.
The ruling landed in the middle of a race that has been anything but settled. Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews sided with the Alaska Division of Elections and said the agency was busy processing the 2026 general election ballots and did not have the bandwidth to produce the report the campaign wanted from the voter registration system.
Matthews made it plain that timing mattered. Even if the request might have been fair at another point in the calendar, he wrote that it was not reasonable now and not required right now, adding that the campaign could hardly have picked a worse time to ask.
Peltola’s team had gone to court last week seeking details on which absentee ballots were marked for rejection and why. The campaign said it wanted a clearer view of a process that, in its telling, was moving along without drama and should not have been treated like some secret operation hidden from observers.
Attorney Abha Kelly argued that the request was not about prying into confidential voter information or throwing a wrench into the count. She said the goal was to bring scattered information into one place so the process could be easier to understand, especially when voters and watchers were already seeing pieces of it in different spots.
State lawyers pushed back hard, saying the records were not public and that privacy still mattered. Assistant Attorney General Margaret Paton-Walsh said voters have a real interest in keeping absentee mistakes from becoming public fodder, especially for people who already worry about making an error while voting from home.
The court fight comes against a backdrop of steady political heat in Alaska, where every ballot seems to matter and every delay gets magnified. The Sullivan campaign was allowed to step into the case, underscoring how much is riding on the records dispute while the broader race stays frozen in a count that refuses to settle quickly.
At the same time, the numbers moved again. With about 86% of the expected vote counted and more than 248,000 ballots in the pile, Peltola held 121,487 first-choice votes, or 48.9%, while Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan sat at 117,512, or 47.3%, leaving a lead of 3,975 votes.
That edge is slim enough to make everyone nervous, but the race still has layers left to peel away. Neither candidate has cracked 50%, so the contest is headed toward ranked-choice tabulation after absentee counting wraps up, with the count expected to continue until around Nov. 18 and certification projected for Nov. 25.
There are also other candidates whose totals could swing the outcome once lower names get removed and second-choice votes get redistributed. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. and Gerald Heikes have enough votes on the board to matter, and their totals are larger than the current gap between the top two contenders.
That is the kind of math that keeps Alaska races alive long after Election Day. The state’s ranked-choice setup keeps forcing campaigns, voters, and lawyers to watch the board one more round at a time, while the repeal effort for that system is itself still hanging in the balance.
