Foreign money has found a slick way into America’s courtroom wars, and it is turning lawsuits into a profitable side hustle for investors who may not pay the same tax bill as everyone else. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has called the practice a “malignancy,” and the outrage around it is easy to understand. The setup lets overseas funds back American litigation, collect a cut of the winnings, and often do it under a tax setup that looks wildly lopsided next to what the actual U.S. plaintiff pays.
Here is the basic problem. A foreign fund helps bankroll a lawsuit, usually by covering steep legal costs, and then gets a prearranged slice of any recovery. The plaintiff’s share is generally taxed like ordinary income, while the foreign financier’s share can be treated like a capital gain, or in some cases face no U.S. tax at all.
That means two people can profit from the same lawsuit and get hit very differently by the tax code. One is an American litigant paying a higher rate, and the other is a foreign backer walking away with a lighter burden or none at all. That is not a loophole that feels like a small technicality. It feels like the system is tilted on purpose.
The larger issue goes beyond taxes. When outside money pours into American litigation, it encourages more lawsuits, more pressure on businesses, and more costs spread across the economy. Those costs do not just stay in the courtroom. They tend to show up later in higher prices for consumers, tighter margins for companies, and more drag on growth.
Bessent’s criticism lands because it connects the dots. He is not just talking about legal finance in the abstract. He is pointing out that foreign investors are exploiting a structure built to reward productive risk-taking, then using it to profit from the opposite of growth, which is endless legal conflict.
That’s what makes the arrangement so hard to defend. The capital gains tax rate exists because the country wants to reward people who put money at risk to build things, hire workers, and expand the economy. Foreign litigation funders are not backing factories, tools, or new jobs. They are backing claims, delays, and payouts that can pull money away from real economic activity.
There is also a basic fairness issue that ordinary taxpayers can spot without needing a law degree. American families already deal with plenty of tax burdens, rising prices, and a legal system that can be expensive and slow. Watching foreign players slip through a favorable tax treatment while Americans shoulder more of the load is exactly the kind of thing that makes people think the game is rigged.
Congress has the power to shut it down, and it should not drag its feet. Lawmakers could close the loophole and steer the extra revenue back toward the taxpayers and toward pro-growth tax relief at home. That would be a cleaner use of the money than letting foreign funds keep gaming American litigation from the sidelines.
There is no real excuse for pretending this is too complicated or too late in the year to fix. The calendar always has room when leaders decide something matters enough, and this one matters. If Congress stalls anyway, the White House and Treasury should look hard at every lawful step available to stop the abuse before it spreads further.
American courts should not be a playground for foreign financiers looking for a tax advantage. When the system rewards speculation over production, everybody pays the price eventually. The faster Washington deals with it, the sooner taxpayers and businesses stop getting squeezed by a racket that should never have been given room to grow.
